I was just perusing the modlog when I noticed something interesting. Apparently posting news about Gaza/Palestine is not allowed on !worldnews@sh.itjust.works. I decided to check the side bar and didn’t see anything. The only pinned post also does not indicate that this is not allowed
edit: the mod in question is @Eyekaytee@aussie.zone . sorry for not originally tagging. i hadn’t realized it was a rule that this must be done. i thought it seemed inappropriate since i was trying to initiate a conversation about a community’s rules and culture rather than start drama about an individual
There are communists within !meanwhileongrad@sh.itjust.works and the community itself allows communists and communist theory. It’s a diverse community where people are free to discuss different topics, unlike your spaces, which regularly censor dissent and criticism.
And you are not a communist, Cowbee, you’re a tankie, you’ve said so yourself.
But tell me, where is this supposed dogwhistling, where is this defence of Israel’s actions, where is this transphobia? I’ll look into it for you
The community of MWoG exists purely to attack communists. I have always said I’m a communist, you can read the screengrab yourself to see:
As for transphobia, here’s your server admin pushing transphobic conspiracy theories in your comm:
As for Zionism, here are your own posts and comments:
I don’t know why I’m responding because I feel you act in extremely bad faith. MoG is a terrible comm, and I think that is why you are seeing transphobia upvoted. I think people see “China bad lol” and are frothing at the mouth upvoting it before even considering wtf he said after it. To say that’s the ENTIRE INSTANCE is so extremely bad faith, or maybe you truly believe that because you haven’t seen any of the normal people on the instance.
Also bad faith to say “tankie” = communist/socialist. That wiki page is also bad faith, unless I have just somehow managed to see it used differently 100/100 times I’ve seen it used as a perjorative. Tankie implies defending Russia and China/ Soviet Union heavily, NOT just being a communist/socialist. Even the Wikipedia page says this… You can disagree but actually ask people if that’s what they mean. If someone says the wikipedia definition and you interpret it as something else without clarifying, you are very likely misinterpreting them. Very bad faith to say “it’s just being communist/socialist bro they just hate good ideologies bro” like cmon be an adult. “Tankie” does not just mean communist. Disgraceful misinforming people just to try and win an argument.
To clarify, I stated that the instance is a Nazi bar, as in there are some massive zionists, fascists, etc. allowed to roam freely, but that this doesn’t describe the entire instance:
Secondly, the word “tankie” in its social use is as an anti-communist pejorative. It’s a strawman with ready-made characteristics built up by anti-communists to avoid actually having to address the arguments of communists. The wikipedia page isn’t maintained by a communist, it’s maintained primarily by liberals, they aren’t looking at it from the communist perspective.
Neither link I sourced was bad-faith, either, unless you mean the communist perspective on a pejorative for communists is inherently bad-faith. It doesn’t matter what an individual specifically means by using “tankie,” in its social practice it just means “communist, but I don’t like it.”
You’re in a tankie instance, Cowbee; you hang out with tankies and repeat tankie talking points. You are a tankie and you’re not fooling anyone with your disingenuous fantasies about being a moralist, if you were, prove it now by criticising the Russian government, or better yet, Chinese imperialism.
You won’t, because you are a tankie.
As for Imaqtpie, I do not approve of him. I have quite the turbulent history with him.
I’ve also been more supportive of trans-rights and gender recognition than you have, Cowbee.
Oh, and even more, the lemmy developers, admins of the instance you use, lemmy.ml, are also transphobic, which is what imaqtpie was agreeing with, funnily enough.
That didn’t work out too well for you lol
“Tankie” is just a pejorative for communist, it isn’t an ideology. Call me “tankie” all you want, but at the end of the day I read Marxist-Leninist theory and volunteer for a Marxist-Leninist org that has stances in line with the rest of Marxist-Leninist organizations. You can’t claim to not be an anti-communist, you maintain an anti-communist comm and oppose communism.
Secondly, showing a handful of times you’ve spoken about sex and gender doesn’t mean you’re more supportive, especially since I have already explained that I disagree firmly with Nutomic:
The Russian government is a homophobic dictatorship of capital. China isn’t imperialist, it doesn’t run its economy based on international plunder, export of capital, nor is it under the control of a financial oligarchy.
Everyone has read theory, Cowbee, you’re not a special sort for reading theory. Though, since you’re such an expert in it, enlighten me, what were Marx’s quotes on Africans and Jews?
cw: antisemitic and racist slurs
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/its-time-talk-about-karl-marxs-racism-181292
And it’s nice you firmly disagree, very neolib of you, writing a firmly worded letter to your master, well done. Here I was thinking that a tankie such as yourself would put a bit of action and elbow-grease into your morals and completely leave lemmy.ml for the developer’s transphobia. Foolish of me.
I never claimed to be an expert in theory, you have to force words into my mouth to craft a narrative that doesn’t exist. You need so very badly for me to be the strawman you’ve created of me, because you can’t actually make any coherent points.
Secondly, Marx was no racist, nor was he anti-semetic. He himself was Jewish, and attacked the anti-semetic hit-piece The Jewish Question. Marx advocated for the liberation of all peoples, linking out of context quotes collected by a far-right anti-communist org doesn’t help you beat the cryptofascist allegations.
As for leaving Lemmy.ml, it’s still useful for talking about theory, and the userbase is very pro-LGBTQ (unlike sh.itjust.works), and I speak far more frequently on the importance of trans rights. Abandoning a space because one of the admins is reactionary just lets the entire narrative there be guided by that.
But you use the ‘I’ve read a lot of theory’ excuse all the time as an attempt to appear as an authority.
If you use racist and antisemitic slurs, then you’re a racist and an antisemite.
Though hey! This will be a golden opportunity for you. Let’s talk about how Russia and China treats its LGBTQI (you forgot the I) population.
I have read theory, yes, and I generally know what I’m talking about when it comes to subjects I have read about. I’m not an expert, and have never claimed to be. I think based on what I have read, I can pretty easily see where people go wrong, or haven’t read the subject.
As for Marx, again, out of context quotations where he is responding to someone using said slurs, or when he is using language common to the time in an attempt to combat racism, is entirely different from the extremely prevalent anti-semetism and racism of the time. You linked a far-right anti-communist article deliberately written to portray something against the reality of the situation, which is par for the course for you.
As for not including the I, you didn’t include the A, or the + either. I used LGBTQ as shorthand, but obviously support LGBTQIA+, this is extremely bad-faith and you know it. I already said Russia is homopbobic, China is improving but has a long way to go.
So why are you in support of Russia and China when both are grossly homophobic and hostile to being queer?
Oh, and that’s not even mentioning North Korea with it’s caste system.
Firstly, stop using my fucking community as a bludgeon against people you don’t like.
Secondly, this is transphobic you numbskull.
Thirdly, y’all are acting like fucking children, Grow Up!
Holy shit, goat edited the link you gave. Like 3 hours ago they edited it, which is after you linked it, and months after they posted it. They removed your evidence.
Incredible, Sartre really didn’t miss with that quote.
The bill gave trans women maternity rights
Yes, and?
that was my point
That doesn’t make your comment less transphobic, and it doesn’t make you and @Cowbee@lemmy.ml any less juvenile for bickering like this on an unrelated post.
ah, i apologise. that wasn’t my intention with my comment.
my intention was that the bill would separate the definitions to better define discrimination and make it more suited to diverse people