Yeah. It’s always a bit pathetic to watch or read about the efforts of cities to make things safer around here.

The scheme that is very popular here to “secure” intersections is to add an exclusive pedestrian phase (a scramble) to the traffic lights cycle. So everyone has to wait for everyone. No pedestrians are crossing while cars are moving through an intersection, and no cars are crossing the intersection while pedestrians are. But it’s tuned for cars and pedestrians have to wait an eternity to have their exclusive phase. So what happens? Pedestrians are eventually losing patience and cross traffic like chickens.

Exclusive phases are also encouraging car drivers never to yield to pedestrians or cyclists, because they never have to. So in some cities where they mainly have this type of crossing, car drivers are not stopping where there’s no traffic lights. Some cities even have to leave orange flags on the side of the road so that pedestrians can wave them in front or cars while crossing.

And don’t get me wrong, scrambles are wonderful for pedestrians when they are in the majority, and when they are configured for pedestrians first. It’s just that some cities here put them at every intersection as a way to separate cars and pedestrians, for safety, and it’s frustrating. And then they scold pedestrians for not waiting “their” turn.

As a pedestrian and cyclist, it’s one of the things I see when I change city. I really don’t like walking in Québec City for this because you have to let cars pass in all the directions first before you are allowed to cross. In Montréal everyone crosses at the same time but they put straight arrows on green lights for a few seconds at the beginning of the cycle, so pedestrians and cyclists have a few seconds to start crossing before cars can try to crush them. And I prefer this. A lot.