All generative AI queries could hit 329 billion per day by 2030. See the big picture on AI’s energy use, and how it’s reshaping our world.
If it’s more than a picowatt-hour, it’s too much.
LLM delenda est.
These figures are too cherry picked for the shock value. You could go the opposite end and say that (these are all true, I’ve tried my best to research them):
8.5 Wh (average of all daily queries for a user) is also…
- Equivalent to running a 2000 W hair dryer or a kettle for 20 seconds
- Equivalent to idling a car during a traffic light and not turning off the engine
- A quarter of the energy required to reheat a ready meal in the microwave (roughly 45 Wh)
- The power usage of a Macbook screen over just 30 minutes.
850 MWh (whole consumption of all AI queries in the world) is also equivalent to…
- The power consumption of ONE single cruise ship for 12h (link)
- Charging 0.002% of the 75 million electric cars in the world
- The energy stored in the fuel tanks of 2000 petrol cars - a small stadium car park in Europe
- The amount of energy the largest solar plant in Spain or Germany generate… In a couple of hours.
So yes - AI bad… But for other reasons. This is a diversion. Datacentres powered by coal are bad. Cruise ships are worse.
The problem isn’t that the whole world needs less than a solar farm’s worth of energy for AI. The bigger problem is the social damage of AI - including the fact that this “expansion at all costs” is justifying getting that energy from non-renewable sources.
But seriously, one single cruise ship uses more energy than all of the AI in the world. They serve no useful purpose and there are hundreds of those.
Datacentres powered by coal are bad. Cruise ships are worse.
Coal Vs Marine fuel. You’ve picked the kings of pollution.
Coal is worse for CO2. The free carbon it releases binds with oxygen in the atmosphere to produce more CO2 mass than the coal itself. It’s crazy how much CO2 it generates.
Heavy fuel oil / bunker oil / marine fuel is cheap ass shit that contains masses of pollutants. So whilst it won’t generate as much CO2, it will create a load of other stuff including Sulphur Dioxide. That creates acid rain.
Here’s an idea. Let’s do neither of them.
Cargo ships are even worse. The amount they pollute is staggering to such a degree that I’m glad trade between the USA and China is strained.
At least they’re doing something. Rampant consumerism aside they’re shipping physical goods in the most efficient way we have available to us. AI though? What the hell is it even doing? It ain’t being helpful that’s for sure, and that’s not even the goal of it, either, so instead of it being “teething problems” is just the usual bullshit of capitalists hurting everyone else over their latest obssession.
You could me cruise ships
Cargo ships are getting way more efficient and less polluting. I work on container ships which have a capacity ranging from 14k to 20k teu.
Imagine transporting these many containers from 1 continent to another via trucks. The amount of pollution they would be emitting on land.
There are strict regulations in place regarding emission. Now with the introduction of dual-fuel ships, they are going to be more environmental friendly.
It’s a concept of the past that cargo ships are pollution factories.
Genuinely glad to hear they’re improving.
Yes my friend.
Also in recent years, huge push for renewable energy from EU, China, India etc. is a step in right direction. It may take time for the world to consume less coal and petroleum, but in the meantime production from renewable source will only increase.
Long way to go, but we are on right path. Maybe our children’s get to see a good future.
Energy usage may not be astronomical right now but AI is going into everything. Like EVERYTHING! It’ll be running even when you don’t think it’s running, when you think it makes no sense to be running. Usage of AI itself will skyrocket and the fastest energy sources that can be acquired are likely to come first.
And it will also become more and more efficient over that time.
And the training beforehand, distributed over models lifetime users?
More on this subject:
“We Went to the Town Elon Musk Is Poisoning”
“We Found the Hidden Cost of Data Centers. It’s in Your Electric Bill”
“We Went to the Town Elon Musk Is Poisoning”
Wait, mobile gas turbines?
What a hack. No permits. And lying about it through gritted teeth.
And they are branded “Solar Turbines”? WTF?
AI bubble will pop by 2030. (I fucking hope.)
Sooner.
None of these AI applications are making money and unlike earlier IT companies (Amazon, Google search, social media site, etc ), the marginal cost of each additional user isn’t near zero.
They are having to invest hundreds of billions to cope with demand for applications which lose money on each use.
It’s a $50 billion dollar industry priced as a trillion dollar industry.
And there‘s still no compelling use-case for the average consumer. Coders and scientists? Can be. But most people don‘t really have a use for it in most situations, even in business contexts. It‘s mostly a solution in search of a problem, and even then it‘s so unreliable that even things trying to sell you it as a solution have to add the disclaimer that you shouldn‘t use it for anything that‘s remotely important.
So even if the costs were markedly less than they are, there‘s still no real path to profitability because there‘s no real call for it.
The only use I‘ve found as a consumer is using something like Perplexity as a search engine. And that‘s not a testament to how good Perplexity is, but instead a testament to how bad other search engines have become. Perplexity just avoids things like SEO and is mostly quite good at finding sources which aren‘t themselves AI-generated.
And…I really see a near future in which AI-SEO becomes a thing and Perplexity et. al. become just as useless as google.
Next to no news on it being stem research, all the hype we are hearing is from csuites and CEO.
I’m with you. I think the markets are going to be demanding results very soon now. When they do…Nvidia, Meta, Google, X, Microsoft stock prices are all going to go into free-fall.
