meler [none/use any]

  • 0 Posts
  • 20 Comments
Joined 19 days ago
cake
Cake day: August 29th, 2025

help-circle





  • It’s soooo good doggirl-tears

    I’m reading into the nonsense quite a bit so I might be wrong but I don’t think it’s circular logic. I think it’s just them misunderstanding how the real numbers are constructed and being VERY confident in their misunderstanding.

    Their notation of Z10^Z makes me think they’re thinking of the reals not as Cauchy sequences of rationals but as functions from Z to Z10. And honestly, I think something like that could be pretty easily (approximately so. Arithmetic would be a pain in the ass to define correctly because you’d be stuck having to worry about carrying your ones in your construction that’s so tightly bound to the base 10 numbering system) converted to something equivalent to the more accepted notion of the reals. And it’s pretty much how we all intuitively think of numbers anyway.

    Their definition of less than also seems to be an attempt at codifying an intuition we all use. None of us ever actually compare reals in our day to day life, unless we’re arguing about 0.999… = 1. Any time we are comparing two numbers that are written out, we start at the leftmost place value and read right until the two numbers differ, and use that place value to determine which of the numbers are bigger. It’s not immediately clear why this intuition wouldn’t work for all reals.

    If it is the case that reals are functions from Z to Z10 and if the intuition of less than from finitely long rationals carries over to the infinitely long ones, than it would imply [0, 1) = [0, 0.999] and therefore 1 =/= 0.999…

    So unless I am completely wrong about what they are trying to argue, I think it’s less circular and more either they think their intuition is the agreed upon definition, or they think their intuition is better than the agreed upon definition.





  • I lost my shit at “it is an elementary exercise to show that [0, 1) = [0, 0.999…].” That’s some comedy gold.

    I love math cranks because a lot of times they are doing something creative. If you to define something in a nonstandard way to see what comes out of it, fuckin’ do it. It’s fun. It’s just absolutely wild when people do that and then turn around and act like what they’ve done is somehow more correct than assumptions made and established, that have centuries of theory built on top of them.

    Who knows? Maybe there’s a universe in which our understanding of the reals was something resembling Z10^Z. I’m not immediately sure how to make sense of arithmetic in this kind of system, but maybe there’s some creativity possible here. And maybe there’s a universe in which calculus has its foundations in infinitesimals. That one feels more likely to me since the early history of calculus did use infinitesimals. Maybe in that universe we just kept thinking about infinitesimals and never developed limits. This would be sad since limits are wayyyy more versitile than infinitesimals and would require every system we have that we want limits in to have infinitesimals as well, but I guess it could have happened that way.

    But we have mountains and mountains and mountains of theory built on the standard definitions, and the thought that we should throw all of that away just to be able to make the assertion that 1 isn’t equal to .999… Is soooooo fucking funny



  • transphobia, hopelessness, ugh

    I don’t regret coming out, but I just wish I could put it on pause just for a day or two so I can breathe. I’m so sick of how people treat me, and I’m so sick of begging people to use my god damn name. I don’t even hate my deadname. I actually kind of like it as a name if I’m being honest. But the downright refusal to use the name I’m explicitly asking people to use just feels like a slap in the face every single time. I’ve told my dad several times now that I don’t want to talk about it anymore, and that he can just do what he wants because I’m done feeling like I have to justify myself to him. I asked him if he saw the possibility of a world in which what he was doing was wrong and he said “I am rarely ever 100% certain about anything, but I’m 100% certain you’re not a woman.” Like at this point trying to talk to him about it is not worth it. But he just keeps fucking bringing it up. Has sent me 5 page long letters written in google docs asking me to see things from his perspective. That he’s trying to do what’s right for me and that I shouldn’t be mad at him for it. The only reason I’m still talking to him at all is because I have $38 in my bank account right now. The financials are kinda shot right now. And sometimes he sends me money. I feel trapped. I just want to leave this god forsaken town in this god forsaken country. I’m so emotionally burnt out and I don’t know what to do.